Monday, April 5, 2010

The Family Reaction to our Adoption

I've seen this post going through blog world, and I thought I would address how our family reacted, as it's been on my mind for quite some time, and I really want to put it out there. I've actually started this post several times, and never liked the tone it ended up taking, so I always ended up erasing it. So, if you are reading this, I finally mustered up the courage to post on this topic!

T and I had been discussing adoption between the two of us for quite some time, but last June 2009, when we decided that we were 100% going to adopt, we decided it was the right time to discuss with our families as well. We were thinking no one would be surprised by our decision to adopt. Afterall, both sets of our families knew about our struggles to conceive, and knew that we had even tried IVF, which also didn't work.

For the most part, our families were very supportive. I remember telling my Mom and Dad first, and they were elated, and not entirely surprised. They were excited to have another grandchild (my sister was pregnant at the time for their first grandchild) and if they did have any apprehension of our Ethiopian adoption, they didn't voice those concerns to us. My siblings were also very excited. My sister started talking about having a playmate for her daughter and the cousins growing up together, and how close in age they would be. My two brothers were excited, and one brother even told me that this is the way it was supposed to be. T and I were receiving a lot of support, and it felt great.

We then told T's family and the reaction was a bit different from his parents and I learned many lessons on religion and culture that I didn't know before. I was assuming we'd have a similar reaction from them. . . a reaction of happiness. They also knew of our struggles to get pregnant, and they knew how much T and I wanted to be parents. I think I've mentioned this before. . . T's parents are from Egypt, and they are Muslims. I had a fast teaching on the Qur'an and learned that adoption is frowned down upon in that religion. T's parents made that quickly known to us, and I would be lying if I said their reaction wasn't hurtful. I don't know what people in Muslim countries do if they cannot have biological children, because adoption usually is not an option.

After their reaction to our adoption, which was less than favorable, I took to studying the Qur'an myself, and found the following verse:

"...Nor has He made your adopted sons your (biological) sons. Such is (only) your (manner of) speech by your mouths. But Allah tells (you) the Truth, and He shows the (right) Way. Call them by (the names of) their fathers; that is juster in the sight of Allah. But if you know not their father's (names, call them) your brothers in faith, or your trustees. But there is no blame on you if you make a mistake therein. (What counts is) the intention of your hearts. And Allah is Oft-Returning, Most Merciful."

This was the verse they were basing their opinion of adoption off of. But to me. . . I read this verse differently than they were reading it. (How typical that a religious verse have many interpretations. This happens in the Bible and other religious books as well) To me, Allah cares what's in your heart. And I know that my heart has the best intentions. I also know that many orphans in Ethiopia don't have a known father. I also know that the Prophet Muhammed himself said that those who will care for an orphaned child, a life in paradise will be waiting them. Muhammed himself even adopted.

I sat down with T's parents and spoke about my research on the Qur'an. They still have a ways to go in terms of coming around fully to the adoption, and I try not to hold resentment when they just do not know any better, nor do they know anyone who has ever adopted. This is new to them, and I need to remind myself of that. T and I are progressive young people in their eyes. T and I embrace the unconventional. Something I do know is that his parents love us and will love our children. And I want to add that T's sibling and family have been so supportive. Our little nieces (his bro's children) talk to us a lot about this boy cousin they are going to have soon. Melts my heart. :)

And it's not just Islam that frowns on adoption. Some other religions do as well. There are Indian religions, predominantly Hindu that believe that adoption ruins the family line, and that children shouldn't be removed from their families and culture and placed in another family and culture.

I have been hesitant to share this story, because there is enough bias and bigotry with different religions already. I don't want someone to read this story and think negatively about any religion. I believe people's beliefs, whatever they may be, deserve respect. I also believe that too many times in religion, the "rules" end up being man-made, and not true to the text of the religious book. And this was definitely true with Islam and the Qur'an. Once I read the Qur'an, I felt like the passages on adoption were being misinterpreted.

And I'm not going to lie. . . It has taken me a while to get rid of the hurt I feel. It was very difficult hearing negative opinions on adoption when it is so close to my heart, and when it is the way to create a family for so many people. I don't believe having difficulty conceiving means that a couple should live childless. To me, adoption is hope.

These were some of the reactions we received. I didn't mention the many more that we received, and 99% of the reactions were joyful elation. It's taken me a lot of thought and prayer to realize that not everyone is up to speed on adoption. T and I have been living and breathing adoption, but others in our life have a learning curve.

All I care about is that when our Ethiopian boy joins our family, that he is treated as nothing less than a member of the family. Because he will be our son. And we will love him as fully as we know how to love. I hope that when Khalil comes home, that the negative reactions and the hurt they cause me, will quickly disappear, and that I'll see these same people love our son.

17 comments:

Erin said...

Hopefully they will come to understand and love your children all as equals.

Did you ever read the Kite Runner? they couldn't conceive and they were going to adopt his servant's son, what they didn't know was his brother at the time, and his family was ashamed. Great book.

Sorry they don't understand. That would hurt me as well. Unfortunately they won't be the only ones that frown on it.

Trinity said...

I have much faith and hope that when Taher's family (and anyone in your life who has some trepidation about adoption) finally meets Khalil and sees what a treasure he is to you both, they will be able broaden their perspective on adoption. When I read the verse in your post, I read it through the same lens as you did: that something done with a full heart is blessed.

I can understand how this was a difficult post to write. Kudos to you for putting it out there! Religion and culture sometimes set up tricky constructs for us, but I am such a hippie in my heart and I pray that love surmounts all.

XX

The Busters said...

I loved this post, Leah! I had to re-read the verse from the Qur'an when you said it was that verse that gave T's parents trepidation because I read it as supporting adoption. It is so interesting how our perspectives and our hearts dictate how we interpret things. I also realized I forgot to comment on T's post and wanted to tell you how much I loved it!!! He sounds like quite a catch and I laughed outloud that the other sad moment for him was soccer related. too funny!!

scooping it up said...

Thank you for sharing Leah. The hard part may really come when your bio child is 5 and son frm ET is 4 and they receive different treatment frmo grandparents on every meeting, every birthday.

This happens all the time, even in families with only bio kids. I know a family who the older TWIN is treated with more attention and love than the other twin.

It is hurtful, painful and can last your entire lives. You have to decide every day how to deal with it, not just once.

I hope they will come around and love him.

Some people in our lives "get" adoption, others support but don't get it, and others don't support and don't get it. It is very easy to not associate with the latter group, but when it's family, it gets complicated. I hope they will learn to support even if they don't get it.

AL said...

I hope that when Khalil comes home, Taher's family's hearts will be opened to adoption. I see that verse the same way you do and I hope that over time they will see it that way too. I can understand how this was a difficult post to write - thank you for sharing.

Kelly said...

Thank you for sharing this, Leah. I know it wasn't easy for you to do. I have actually wondered how T's family is with the adoption, because I had thought that they might not be supportive. While of course we can't see into the future, I venture to bet that they will love K as much as possible, and come around to respecting and embracing your family-building choice. It's just got to be very difficult for them, since they believe their religion frowns upon adoption and they don't have any experience. It sounds like you did a great job of doing your own research and also of speaking freely with them.

Leah Maya Benjamin said...

What a great post! our families were both beyond excited and i am sorry that you got hurt. My husbands siblings are both adopted along with a bunch of other family members. I was surprised at your in laws feelings. One of the people I lived with in Guatemala was muslim and we were both there takign care of our children before we could come home. She was from Afganistan and her husband from India, now they are adopting from Ethiopia,I never heard anything from her about their religion having issues with adoption, I did hear that if she could not breastfeed her daughter then at a certian age, I think 12 years then she would have to cover her head in front of her father.

Kala said...

I know this was a hard post. Thanks for sharing :)

Jewls said...

I bet when he gets here they'll recognize how he's meant to be in your family!

Andrea said...

Oh Leah,

I have often wondered how adoption would be received in mine and my husbands families. I've wondered if our parents would have the ability to love an adopted child the same as the biological children of hubby and my siblings. I also wonder how our friends would react....so much to ponder, as I don't worry about myself, as I can take it, but I would NEVER want my child to feel less loved or cared for.

Getting back on track, I can understand the generational difference in how T's parents feel, but as you say, they are products of what they have been taught. It's sad though, as they are denying themselves a wonderful gift. However, children are known to steal hearts :) I pray that T's parents will love and accept your little boy, as Kalil deserves only love and I KNOW you and T will give him a plethora of LOVE :)

I can't even imagine all that you have been through Leah...and I'm sorry, as I know it hasn't been easy, but I admire your strength. You deserve all this happiness. Continue living in the moment and thank you for writing this honest post :)

Many prayers to you and T and well wishes as you continue to build your family.

xo

Deni said...

I do not know a lot about other religions and I just want you to know how much I appreciated this post. I think all religions should be respected, as I wouldn't want someone to expect me to change my beliefs simply because they didn't agree. Thank you for sharing the excerpt from the Qur'an, as I saw it the way you did. And I agree that texts are constantly being interpretted different ways, and people justify horrible things through them.

I'm so enjoying learning from you! Thank you! And I know they will have nothing but love for Khalil when he arrives, I can't wait to see pictures of your beautiful family!!!

Sunny Haralson said...

People can(and seem to) get over even the craziest biases. My entire Evangelical, super conservative family treats my lesbian cousin and her longtime girlfriend with love and respect now. How brave of you guys to do what's right in your heart. everyone else will follow, given time.

Hillary said...

It sounds like you and T are really loving his family through this, and, like you said, you know they will love your son. It could be "easy" to just get mad and offended and distance yourself from them, but you are doing an amazing job letting the dust settle and trusting it will work out.

Mayme said...

Our decision to adopt Emma was not well received at first by my in-laws. It was a very difficult time in our relationship and will always be a moment that I remember with much hurt. However, we knew God had led us to adopt Emma. Now everytime I see my father-in-law spoiling our girl, a little part of me just wants to scream "See there, I told you so!" I refrain, but oh do I think about it!

roy/elisabeth dean said...

I think when Khalil's grandparents see him and hold him for the first time, all they will feel is love for their precious gift!
I'm beyond ecstatic for all of you!
Take good care of yourself~
♥,Lilly

Anonymous said...

It's not just certain religions who are biased against adoption. Asians, especially Koreans have strong views on bloodline, so there is bias towards adopting. If they adopt, they prefer to adopt within the extended family, although younger generation is more open. I believe that in Muslim cultures if they were infertile, they prefer to adopt, it would be a brother's child.

Anonymous said...

Great story as for me. I'd like to read something more about this theme. The only thing I would like to see here is some photos of some gizmos.

Katherine Karver
pocket cell phone jammer